What’s right for her account isn’t right for yours
If you’re a nutritional therapist, you’ve probably said some version of this to a client more times than you can count. ‘Just because it worked for your friend doesn’t mean it’s right for you.’ The magnesium her sister swears by. The protocol a colleague did wonders on. The supplement that went round the WhatsApp group. You know that what works depends on the person, their history and where their body is right now.
Then you open Instagram, see a peer in your field with 15,000 engaged followers posting a trending template and picking up hundreds of new followers overnight, and you think, right, I’ll do that. You do it. Forty views. Two of them are your mum.
It isn’t that your content is worse or that you’re doing it wrong. It’s that Instagram isn’t one thing. The account that’s already established and the account that’s still being built operate under completely different conditions, and the same post does a completely different job depending on which one posts it. This post breaks down the difference and what a building account should be doing instead.
Contents
Instagram isn’t one platform, it’s many
The established account vs the building account
Where the two really differ
Which strategy should you follow?
Why all this noise makes it harder
FAQs
1. Instagram isn’t one platform, it’s many
We talk about ‘Instagram’ as if it’s a single set of rules everyone plays by. It isn’t. What Instagram does with your post depends heavily on who already knows you, how they’ve interacted with you before, and whether there’s any existing relationship for that post to land on.
A large, engaged account has years of signals behind it. Instagram knows who likes her content, who comments, who saves, and it can put a new post in front of those people with a reasonable expectation that they’ll respond. A small account has very little of that. Every post is, in effect, asking strangers for attention.
So when you look at a bigger account in your field and try to work out what they’re doing, you’re looking at the result of a strategy designed for their situation, not yours. It’s the client who wants to start on the advanced protocol before you’ve even looked at the basics.
2. The established account vs the building account
The established account
By established, I don’t just mean a big number. Plenty of accounts have 10,000 followers and an audience that has long since stopped paying attention. I mean an account with a substantial, engaged following: people who know who she is, recognise her face, and are interested in what she thinks. Some of them are fans, not just followers. That distinction matters more than the follower count.
An established account can post about her morning, her opinions, her holiday, a behind-the-scenes clip or a trending template, and it will land, because there’s already a relationship. People are interested in her, so content about her works.
The building account
The building account is everyone else. Maybe a few hundred followers, maybe a couple of thousand, with views that rarely leave the people who already follow you. Here’s the uncomfortable part: the people you need to reach don’t know who you are, and right now they don’t care. That isn’t a criticism. It’s just where you are.
They’re not on Instagram looking for you. They’re half-watching telly or sitting in a waiting room, scrolling without much intent. Your job isn’t to share your personality with an audience that isn’t there yet. It’s to earn their attention in the first place.
3. Where the two really differ
Who’s watching
The established account is mostly talking to people who already know her, plus the new people Instagram sends her way on the back of that engagement. The building account is mostly talking to strangers, or to nobody new at all. Before anything else, you need reach. Polishing captions and perfecting your grid is optimising content that nobody new is seeing yet.
What a post is for
For the established account, a post can deepen a relationship that already exists. For the building account, a post has one job: interrupt a passive scroll with something that feels immediately relevant to the person you want to help. That means leading with their problem, not your news. It’s give, give, give. Useful, recognisable, specific content that makes the right person stop and think, ‘that’s me’.
Why the trending template works for her and not for you
You’ll have seen these. A trending audio or a template in the app, and someone posting ‘I gained 2,000 followers with this trend, so here’s my crack at it.’ It’s tempting to read that as proof the trend works. What it actually proves is that the trend works for an account whose audience is already curious about the person behind it.
Most of these formats are personality-led. They’re fun, they’re a bit of a wink to people who already follow along, and they rely on the viewer caring who’s doing it. Post the same thing from an account nobody knows and there’s nothing for it to stick to. The cold viewer sees a stranger doing a trend, learns nothing about how you could help them, and keeps scrolling.
Variety vs repetition
An established account has room to vary. Her audience already knows what she stands for, so a change of topic or tone doesn’t confuse anyone. A building account doesn’t have that luxury. When people are only catching the odd glimpse of you, variety just looks like noise. Repetition is what builds recognition. Find your thing and say it, in different ways, until people could finish your sentences for you. You will be bored long before your audience is, and that’s fine.
The viral exception
Yes, every so often a tiny account goes viral with a trend by sheer chance. It happens. It’s also the ultimate exception to the rule, and building a strategy around it is like building a practice around the one client who got better on a protocol that shouldn’t have worked - that situation that you simply cannot explain. You can be pleased for them. You don’t base your clinical approach on them.
4. Which strategy should you follow?
If you’re in building mode, you need a building strategy. There isn’t one fixed way to do that, but the principles don’t change much: pick a clear path, stick with it, and repeat your core message until it lands. Give before you ask for anything, including asking people to be interested in you.
That doesn’t mean personality is banned until you hit some magic number. It means it isn’t the lead yet. Bring yourself in once people have started caring, and you’ll know when that is. People comment back your own phrases. They message you saying they’ve been watching for a while. Your follower growth stops depending on one lucky reel. At that point, the trending template that fell flat a year ago might actually work, because now there’s someone on the other end who wants to see you do it.
It’s the same thing you’d tell a client. Start with the foundations that suit where you are now. The advanced stuff comes later, and it works better because the groundwork is there.SEO is getting your website found on Google. GEO, or generative engine optimisation, is getting it found in AI answers, like the summaries at the top of Google or a reply from ChatGPT.
You'll also see AEO (answer engine optimisation) and LLM SEO. Google lumps them all together: 'Good GEO, AEO, LLM SEO is good SEO'.
New name, same foundations.
5. Why all this noise makes it harder
The hardest part of this isn’t knowing it. It’s holding onto it while you’re surrounded by accounts doing something else. Every scroll puts another ‘this worked for me’ in front of you, and the more you consume, the more your own content starts to drift toward it.
The brain that scrolls isn’t the brain you need to create with. As a consumer, you’re drawn to novelty and variety. As a business owner building an account, your audience needs the opposite: clarity, familiarity and the same message again. If you’re going to scroll for work, scroll for audio and get out. Everything else distracts from the simple basics that actually build an account.
This is the thinking behind Found & Followed, my 3-month Instagram programme for women in wellness. It’s built specifically for accounts in building mode, using Instagram’s Trial Reels to get your content in front of people who don’t follow you yet, with a daily method designed around repetition and compounding growth rather than chasing trends. It still takes work, but it’s work pointed in the right direction. You can find out more and join the waitlist for the next cohort here.
6. FAQs
Why do trending reels work for some accounts and not mine?
Most trending formats are personality-led, so they rely on the audience already being interested in the person posting. An established account has that interest built up. A small account usually doesn’t yet, so the same format has nothing to hold onto.
How many followers do I need before I can post more personal content?
There isn’t a number. Engagement and recognition matter more than follower count. When people start responding to you, quoting your ideas back and coming to you directly, you’ve built enough of a relationship to bring more of yourself in.
Should I stop following bigger accounts in my field?
Not necessarily, but be honest about what consuming their content does to your own. If you find yourself copying formats that don’t suit where your account is, limit how much you scroll and use that time to create instead.
Is it worth trying to go viral as a small account?
Viral moments do happen, but they’re rare and unpredictable. A strategy built on consistent reach and repetition will grow your account far more reliably than waiting for one lucky reel.
Download my free stuff
Five fixes for your website that you can make in an afternoon, without hiring anyone or learning to speak SEO. They cover getting Google to notice your new pages faster, using links between your own pages to push up the ones that matter, and the character counts for titles and descriptions so they don’t get cut off in search results. They also show which pages to hide from Google and why clearing out old pages helps the rest of your site. There’s a note on where to find each setting in Squarespace too.
If everything ChatGPT writes for you needs rewriting before it sounds like you, this is the fix. It’s a fill-in-the-blanks template for ChatGPT’s personalisation settings, where you tell it once who your practice supports, how you write, which phrases you use and which make you wince, and that it mustn’t give personalised medical advice. It comes with character targets for each section so everything fits, and examples written for nutritional therapists and wellness practitioners. You set it up once and it applies to every chat after that.
I’m Sam. I’ve spent the best part of a decade doing marketing for everyone from a fashion house to a TV presenter, and somewhere along the way I realised the people I most wanted to help were nutritional therapists and functional medicine practitioners. That was five years ago, and I’ve barely worked with anyone else since. I look after the whole of a practice’s online marketing, from the website and SEO to social media and everything that ties them together, for practitioners who are brilliant at what they do and tired of being the best-kept secret. I don’t do strategy decks that sit in a drawer. I do marketing that actually gets done.
Oh, and when the Trial Reels system I developed got my clients millions of views and thousands of new followers, I turned it into an Instagram course called Found & Followed. Register your interest here.